Kirkus Review
Scary radicals par excellence, the Black Panthers took pains to set the terms of their depiction in the media and popular culture--and apart from Forrest Gump, they were largely successful. So notes Rhodes (American Studies/Macalester College) in this study of the shaping of the Panther image and icon. The N-word-charged scene in which Panthers shake down poor Tom Hanks notwithstanding--a scene that is "little more than a contrivance to highlight Gump's innocence against the backdrop of such inflammatory rhetoric"--and the Panthers' depiction of the media as lackeys of the ruling class and therefore enemies, the party was concerned to cultivate a heroic, positive image, at once defiant and statesmanlike. Huey Newton and Bobby Seale, for instance, were careful to instruct the "pigs" that any attempt to crack down on their fellow Panthers or the black Bay Area neighborhoods in which they operated would be met with violence, insisting that their stance was defensive. The party was little known outside the Bay Area at first, but local sympathies were translated at a national level. Icons piled on icons--Rhodes notes that the famed photo of Newton seated with a shotgun in one hand and spear in the other went against his contempt for "black cultural nationalists' embrace of African symbols," but it made good suitable-for-framing revolutionary art all the same, picked up by the most mainstream of media. Most of Rhodes's referents will be familiar to anyone who was present at the time, and her narrative seldom picks up above a scholarly trudge, but she does her readers a good turn by extending the Panther story to the present--for, as she reminds us, there are still old Panthers doing good deeds in the black community, even as Islamist "New Panthers" attempt to appropriate the old icons and images for their own causes. Good reading for the Baudrillard set--and for students of '60s politics generally. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Choice Review
By telling the story of the cultural symbolism of the Black Panther Party, which may or may not have conformed to its reality, Rhodes (Macalester College) shows the importance of the way the public "frames" its perception of movements and events. In less scholarly terms, "It is the image that counts--the branding." Confirming that the Black Panthers "remain a potent symbol of Black resistance and the nation's racial crisis gone amok," she documents with a storyteller's grace how that iconic power evolved in press, television, film, FBI and law enforcement analyses, autobiographies, scholarship, and self-representation. Rhodes insightfully compares what actually happened in the party with its growing image and reputation. She points out that the black panther stood as a symbol before the party existed, and remains a memory and legacy whose ownership claimants fight. Rhodes's exhaustive, well-recorded scholarly research is told with a skill that makes this book readable and intriguing. It is of value to anyone interested in the Black Panthers, the nature of the social revolutions of the civil rights-Black Power era, or the interaction of symbolism and firsthand reality in history. It is time for other groups to receive the study that Rhodes has given the Black Panthers. Good historiography. Summing Up: Recommended. All levels/libraries. J. H. Smith Wake Forest University
